Spirit and history: the cunning of reason
1 min read
In the Philosophy of History, Hegel describes world history as the progress of the consciousness of freedom. Spirit realises itself in time through the actions of individuals and peoples. But individuals act from their passions and interests; they do not intend the universal result. Hegel calls this the "cunning of reason" (List der Vernunft): reason uses the particular aims of human beings to achieve its own end.
This does not mean that history is a hidden plan imposed from outside. Spirit is not a separate agent; it is the self-unfolding of freedom in the world. The state, for Hegel, is the actuality of the ethical idea—the institution in which freedom becomes concrete. World-historical individuals are those whose particular purposes coincide with the next necessary stage of the universal.
The thesis is controversial: it can sound like a theodicy that justifies suffering. Hegel's claim is rather that philosophy comprehends what has happened, not that everything that happens is good.
Averrois
/u/averrois
Knowledge is the conformity of the object and the intellect.
Thread
- Is this a theodicy?/u/averrois
Whether the cunning of reason amounts to a theodicy that justifies suffering, and how to read Hegel's "rational is actual" without that conclusion.
- World-historical individuals/u/averrois
The role of world-historical individuals: their particular aims and the universal result in Hegel's philosophy of history.