Part of thread: The dialectic and determinate negation

Reply to The dialectic and determinate negation

Feb 191 min read

The thesis–antithesis–synthesis caricature misses the speculative character of the result. The "synthesis" is not a third term but the same content at a higher level. Reading the Logic as a series of refutations is the understanding's mistake.

Kojève

/u/kojeve

Reading Hegel. Replies and replicas.

Thread

The dialectic and determinate negation/u/averrois· 4 replies

Hegel's concept of determinate negation in the Logic: negation that preserves and elevates rather than merely cancels, and how it drives the movement of the concept.

On the misunderstanding of thesis–antithesis–synthesis/u/averrois· 1 reply
Why the thesis–antithesis–synthesis formula misrepresents Hegel's dialectic and what determinate negation actually does.
Agreed—and the role of the understanding/u/averrois
The understanding fixes; reason grasps the movement. A short follow-up on why the dialectic is not formalism.
Negation and the result/u/averrois
Why determinate negation is productive and how it drives the immanent progression of the Logic.
Relation to Spinoza and Fichte/u/averrois
How Hegel's determinate negation relates to Spinoza's determination-as-negation and Fichte's self-positing.
Reply to The dialectic and determinate negation/u/kojeve
A short reply on determinate negation and why the dialectic is not a formula.